
AI News Headlines Deep Dive: MIT's 95% Pilot Failure Report & Top 100 Gen AI Consumer Apps
Jason and Ryan take a break from hands-on demonstrations to discuss two significant AI industry reports that made headlines this week. They begin with MIT's report claiming that 95% of generative AI pilots are failing, immediately questioning the methodology, sample size, and success criteria definitions. The hosts emphasize the importance of healthy skepticism when evaluating such claims, noting that most businesses and new features fail regardless of AI involvement, making high failure rates potentially normal rather than AI-specific. They then shift to analyzing the 'Top 100 Gen AI Consumer Apps' report, highlighting issues with categorization as many listed 'consumer' apps like Cursor are actually developer tools. The discussion reveals insights about character AI platforms like Character.ai dominating usage, the emergence of vibe coding platforms (Lovable, Bolt, Replit) showing more builders than users of created apps, and Supabase's dominance as the backend platform of choice for new developers. Throughout the episode, Jason and Ryan demonstrate critical thinking in evaluating industry reports, emphasizing the need to understand data sources, methodologies, and potential biases in AI industry coverage.
Jump To
Key Takeaways
- Question the data: Both reports lack transparency in methodology, sample size, and success criteria definitions, requiring healthy skepticism when evaluating such claims
- Context matters for 'failure': Most businesses and new features fail regardless of AI involvement, so high failure rates may reflect normal market dynamics rather than AI-specific issues
- Success metrics are crucial: Without clear definitions of what constitutes success or failure, reports can be misleading and support convenient narratives
- Consumer vs developer tools blur: Many 'consumer' AI apps like Cursor are actually developer tools, highlighting the challenge of categorizing AI applications
- Vibe coding platforms show promise: Tools like Lovable, Bolt, and Replit are enabling more builders than users of their created apps, suggesting growing interest in citizen development
- Supabase emergence: The database platform's dominance in vibe coding tools demonstrates the importance of easy-to-integrate backend services for new developers
Resources
r/Futurology - MIT report: 95% of generative AI pilots at companies are failing
Report claiming 95% of generative AI pilots are failing (Fortune, paywalled)
r/ArtificialInteligence - MIT says 95% of enterprise AI fails — but here’s what the 5% are doing right
Report claiming 95% of generative AI pilots are failing (Fortune, paywalled)
Top 100 Gen AI Consumer Apps Report
Report analyzing the top performing generative AI consumer applications